US court lets frozen potato price-fixing case against four processors proceed
On 17 Sep 2026 a US federal judge in Illinois let a price-fixing lawsuit against Lamb Weston, McCain, J.R. Simplot, Cavendish Farms and data firm Circana move forward, granting dismissal motions only in part. The stay on discovery has been lifted, defendants were due to answer by 13 Oct 2026, and the next docket date is 1 Dec 2026.
Why it matters
The four processors named in the case supply nearly all frozen fries and other frozen potato products sold in the US, so the litigation reaches a large part of North American processing. With discovery now open, the case also tests whether pooling commercial data through a benchmarking service can itself breach antitrust law, a question for any processor that shares figures with industry data platforms.
Judge Jeffrey I. Cummings of the US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois issued a 58-page memorandum opinion and order on 17 Sep 2026 in In re Frozen Potato Products Antitrust Litigation (No. 24-cv-11801). He granted part of the defendants' joint motion to dismiss and denied separate motions from Circana and McCain Foods Limited (court order, published by plaintiffs' counsel Cohen Milstein).
Who is suing, and over what?
Three proposed classes bring the claims: direct purchasers who buy from the processors, commercial indirect purchasers, and consumers. They allege that Lamb Weston, McCain, J.R. Simplot and Cavendish Farms swapped competitively sensitive information through PotatoTrack, a platform run by Circana, and held prices of fries, hash browns, tater tots and similar products at inflated levels, in breach of the Sherman Act and state antitrust and consumer protection laws. The first complaint was filed on 15 Nov 2024 by Redner's Markets; consolidated complaints followed on 6 Oct 2025.
At this stage the court must treat the plaintiffs' factual allegations as true. The ruling does not find that any company broke the law.
How concentrated is the market, according to the complaints?
The plaintiffs say the four producers hold about 98% of the US frozen potato products market: Lamb Weston 40%, McCain 30%, Simplot 20% and Cavendish 7 to 8%. They value the US market at about USD 68 billion in 2023.
What did the court throw out?
The partial grant affects some state-law claims. For example, indirect purchasers' claims under South Dakota antitrust law were dismissed for lack of specific allegations about sales in that state.
What happens next?
The defendants were ordered to answer the complaints by 13 Oct 2026, and the stay on discovery was lifted. The parties had to file a joint status report by 27 Oct 2026 proposing a schedule for fact and expert discovery and updating the court on settlement talks. The court reset a status hearing to 1 Dec 2026, for tracking only.
Key numbers
| Figure | Value | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Combined US market share of the four processors (alleged) | 98 percent | 17 Sep 2026 | Source |
| Lamb Weston US market share (alleged) | 40 percent | 17 Sep 2026 | Source |
| US frozen potato products market value, 2023 (alleged) | 68 USD billion | 17 Sep 2026 | Source |
| Deadline for defendants to answer | 13 Oct 2026 date | 17 Sep 2026 | Source |
Sources
- In re Frozen Potato Products Antitrust Litigation, No. 24-cv-11801, Memorandum Opinion and Order (17 Sep 2026) · US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (via Cohen Milstein) (primary source)